Is the Black Copper Marans or Buff Orpington a better egg layer?

The Black Copper Marans lays about 150–200 eggs a year; the Buff Orpington lays about 180–280. The Buff Orpington is the stronger layer — about 180–280 eggs a year against the Black Copper Marans's 150–200.

Black Copper Marans vs Buff Orpington — which is better for beginners?

Both the Black Copper Marans and the Buff Orpington are beginner-friendly and forgiving of first-time mistakes.

Black Copper Marans photo: seppingsR (CC BY 2.0) · Buff Orpington photo: Pete Cooper (CC BY 2.0) · via Wikimedia Commons

Black Copper Marans vs Buff Orpington

Two backyard favorites, side by side — egg production, temperament, size, and hardiness, straight from our breed data. Here's how to choose.

The quick verdict

The Buff Orpington is the stronger layer — about 180–280 eggs a year against the Black Copper Marans's 150–200.

The Black Copper Marans lays chocolate brown eggs; the Buff Orpington lays brown.

The Buff Orpington goes broody often — a bonus if you want a hen to hatch her own chicks, a hassle if you'd rather she keep laying like the Black Copper Marans.

Both dual purpose birdsBoth cold-hardyBoth beginner-friendlyBoth calm and easy to handle

Choose the Black Copper Marans if you want…

Chocolate brown eggs for the basket
Rarely quits laying to sit on eggs

Full Black Copper Marans profile →

Choose the Buff Orpington if you want…

More eggs — up to 280 a year
Will hatch and raise her own chicks

Full Buff Orpington profile →

Side by side

Trait	Black Copper Marans	Buff Orpington
Purpose	Dual purpose	Dual purpose
Eggs per year	150–200	✓180–280
Egg color	Chocolate brown	Brown
Egg size	Large	Large
Hen weight	6–7 lbs	7–8 lbs
Temperament	Gentle and quiet	Affectionate and docile
Cold hardy	Yes	Yes
Heat tolerant	No	No
Broodiness	Sometimes broody	Often broody
Beginner friendly	Yes	Yes

Egg counts are healthy-hen peaks; real numbers dip in winter, during molt, and as a hen ages. Size a coop for either bird with our coop size calculator.

More head-to-heads

Australorp vs Black Copper Marans Barred Plymouth Rock vs Black Copper Marans Black Copper Marans vs Rhode Island Red Black Copper Marans vs Olive Egger Black Copper Marans vs Welsummer Buff Orpington vs Cochin

Or browse every comparison · see all 51 breeds

Black Copper Marans or Buff Orpington — track whichever you pick

Give every bird a profile in PoultryPal, log their eggs and weight, and let the app show you which hen is really your best layer. Free on iOS and Android.